Knuckle Cracking and Arthritis: What Studies Show
Ukraine, Dnepr, st. 25 Sicheslavskaya Brigade (Rybinskaya St.), 119 ‑ 120
Ukraine, Dnepr, st. 25 Sicheslavskaya Brigade (Rybinskaya St.), 119 ‑ 120

Knuckle Cracking and Arthritis: What Studies Show

What studies on knuckle cracking showed: link with hand osteoarthritis in 215 people, 40 adults examined, where the sound comes from, when to see a doctor.

Knuckle Cracking and Arthritis: What Studies Show
Knuckle cracking and hand osteoarthritis: what studies in people showed, where the sound comes from, what happens to mobility and grip strength, and when to see a doctor.

The main point

Good news for those who like to crack their knuckles: studies in people found no link between cracking and hand osteoarthritis. Osteoarthritis is wear of the cartilage in a joint. In everyday speech people often say "arthritis", but the studies were about hand osteoarthritis. In an American study, doctors examined 215 people aged 50–89, and 18.0% of people with hand osteoarthritis (135 people) and 23.2% of people without it (80 people) cracked their knuckles. People with osteoarthritis did not crack more often. In another study, in which doctors who did not know who cracked examined 40 healthy adults, no one had swelling, and grip strength did not differ between crackers and non-crackers. These are observations at a single point in time, not over many years, so it cannot yet be claimed that there is no harm at all.

What was studiedHow many peopleWhat was foundWhat it means
Cracking and hand osteoarthritis, survey and radiology reports215 people (135 with osteoarthritis, 80 without)18.0% with osteoarthritis and 23.2% without crackedNo link with osteoarthritis was found
Examination by doctors who did not know who cracks40 people (30 crack daily, 10 never)No swelling, similar grip strengthNo immediate harm is seen
Joint mobility right after cracking62 cracked joints out of 400Passive range 137.8° → 145.6°A small increase, significance unclear
MRI during cracking1 man, 10 jointsA cavity appeared in the jointShowed what happens in the joint at the moment of the sound; the mechanism is debated

Where the sound comes from

The sound occurs in the joint when it is stretched. In an American ultrasound study, a bright flash appeared in 50 of 62 cracked joints, that is 81%. The authors think a gas cavity forms in the joint. On magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in one man, 10 finger joints were shown: in all ten a dark cavity appeared at the crack, and the joint space at the moment of the crack became wider: on average from 0.93 to 1.89 mm. The authors link the sound to the formation of a cavity. The mechanism remains a matter of debate, and it cannot be said for certain "this is a bursting bubble".

What about osteoarthritis

In the main study, doctors sent out 329 questionnaires, and 215 people replied (65%). Cracking was determined by self-report, and osteoarthritis was taken from radiologist reports. 43 of the 215 people cracked, that is 20%. The most important figure: 18.0% with osteoarthritis against 23.2% without it. The number of years of cracking and "crack-years" (times per day multiplied by years) were not linked to osteoarthritis. Age (1.20 times higher odds for each year) and a family history of hand osteoarthritis (2.98 times higher odds) were linked to osteoarthritis. The groups differed by age: 64.4 years against 57.0, but in the age-adjusted calculation no link between cracking and osteoarthritis was found anyway.

Mobility and grip strength

In the second study, 40 healthy adults aged 33–34 on average (30 crack daily, 10 never) were examined by orthopaedic doctors: each was examined by one of two who did not know which group they belonged to. A questionnaire on hand function gave 3.7 in crackers and 3.2 in non-crackers, both normal. Grip strength, measured with a dynamometer, did not differ: right hand 83.8 vs 77.9 lb, that is about 38.0 and 35.3 kg. No one had swelling, including right after cracking. After stretching the joints, the passive range of motion of the finger was slightly greater in crackers: 143.8° vs 134.9°. After the cracking of 62 joints it rose from 137.8° to 145.6°. The authors call the clinical significance of this increase unclear. Separately: on the Beighton score (0–9 points, joint looseness; 4 and above is a sign) crackers averaged 2.0 points, non-crackers 0.3; both groups were below the threshold, and the authors found no significant difference.

What was said earlier

In 1990, according to the abstract of a study of 300 patients aged 45 and older (74 crack, 226 do not), hand swelling and weaker grip were more often noted in crackers. The abstract gives no figures for these findings, while in 2017 in 40 young adults (average age 33–34) doctors who did not know who cracked found neither swelling nor a difference in grip. A 1975 study, by its abstract, found no link between cracking and joint changes in elderly patients. In a 1998 letter a doctor described his own experience, one person, which is not evidence (Unger DL Arthritis Rheum 1998. PMID 9588755). In a small study of 35 crackers and 35 age-matched peers, grip strength did not differ, while the cartilage of the metacarpal heads (the ends of the bones at the base of the fingers) on ultrasound was thicker in crackers aged 19–27.

Important

If cracking comes with pain, swelling, the joints turn red or swell, or the fingers do not bend well, it is worth seeing a doctor. The authors also remind of rare reports of injuries from very forceful cracking. There is no need to pull a joint through pain. For people with already known arthritis or osteoarthritis, first a conversation with the doctor about the load on the hands.

What the studies showed

StudyWho took partResultSource
Cracking and hand osteoarthritis, case-control215 people aged 50–89 (135 and 80)18.0% with osteoarthritis and 23.2% without crackeddeWeber K J Am Board Fam Med 2011. PMID 21383216
Examination and ultrasound, blinded assessment40 people, 400 jointsNo swelling, similar grip, range of motion after cracking 137.8° → 145.6°Boutin RD Clin Orthop Relat Res 2017. PMID 28050816
Examination of patients aged 45 and older (abstract)300 people (74 crack, 226 do not)No more hand arthritis, swelling and weak grip reportedCastellanos J Ann Rheum Dis 1990. PMID 2344210
Survey of elderly patients (abstract)number not given in the abstractNo link with joint changes foundSwezey RL West J Med 1975. PMID 1130029
MRI during cracking1 man, 10 jointsA cavity in the joint, wider joint spaceKawchuk GN PLoS One 2015. PMID 25875374
Cracking and cartilage, ultrasound (abstract)35 crackers and 35 age-matched peersSimilar grip, cartilage thicker in crackersYildizgören MT Hand Surg Rehabil 2017. PMID 28137441
A doctor's letter about himself1 personDescription of his own experienceUnger DL Arthritis Rheum 1998. PMID 9588755

Summary

According to studies in people, no link between knuckle cracking and hand osteoarthritis was found: 18.0% of people with osteoarthritis (135 people) and 23.2% of people without it (80 people) cracked their knuckles. In 40 adults the examination found no swelling and no difference in grip strength. There are no long-term follow-up studies yet. You can go through your own situation at a consultation.

Source: Knuckle Cracking and Arthritis: What Studies Show — universum.earth. Dr. Pereligyn.

Come back
Request a call back