Calcium tablets: are they needed for bones, and do they harm the heart
Ukraine, Dnepr, st. 25 Sicheslavskaya Brigade (Rybinskaya St.), 119 ‑ 120
Ukraine, Dnepr, st. 25 Sicheslavskaya Brigade (Rybinskaya St.), 119 ‑ 120

Calcium tablets: are they needed for bones, and do they harm the heart

Bones need calcium, and food is the place to start. For whom tablets with vitamin D lower fracture risk, how to take calcium and what to space it apart from, and what is known about the heart and kidney stones.

Calcium tablets: are they needed for bones, and do they harm the heart
Calcium is the main mineral of bone, and getting enough of it matters at any age. Food is the place to start. The data on tablets differ: a review of trials in people living at home found no link with fractures, while in the Cochrane review calcium tablets with vitamin D slightly lowered the risk of hip fracture: with the same relative risk, at home that is about 1 fewer fracture per 1000 people per year, and in care institutions, where fractures are more common, about 9. In plain words: how much calcium you need, where to get it, how to take tablets correctly, and what is known about the heart and kidneys.

Key points

Calcium is the main mineral of bone; the table shows how it helps and what human studies showed.

Where it appliesHow it helpsWhat human studies showed
Bones and the whole bodythe basis of the skeleton: bones hold 99% of the body’s calcium, about 1 kg; it is also needed for blood clotting, the work of muscles, including the heart, and nerves (Burgerstein, Handbuch Nährstoffe 2015, p. 92–93); the US Institute of Medicine norm is 700–1300 mg a day, depending on age (Ross AC J Am Diet Assoc 2011. PMID 21443983)—
Food as a sourcethe easiest way to reach the norm is with dairy products; it is possible without dairy too, for example with kalein 11 women, 41% of the calcium from kale was absorbed, and 32% from milk (Heaney RP Am J Clin Nutr 1990. PMID 2321572)
Fractures in older people (together with vitamin D)slightly lowers the risk of hip fracture and of any fracturein the Cochrane review, relative risk of hip fracture 0.84 (9 studies, 49,853 people); by the authors’ calculation, at the same relative risk this is about 1 fewer fracture per 1000 older people per year at home (0 to 2) and about 9 in long-term care institutions, where fractures are more common; any fracture 0.95 (Avenell A Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2014. PMID 24729336)
Bone density (together with vitamin D)the hip bone is slightly denserin the WHI study, in 36,282 healthy postmenopausal women aged 50–79 taking 1000 mg of calcium and 400 IU of vitamin D3 for 7 years, hip bone density was 1.06% higher than on placebo (Jackson RD N Engl J Med 2006. PMID 16481635)

How it helps

Food comes first

The easiest way to reach the norm is with dairy products: milk, kefir, yogurt, cheese. If you eat little dairy, count the calcium using the labels.

It is possible without dairy too: calcium from kale, which is low in oxalates, was absorbed even better than from milk (41% vs 32%), while from spinach, according to earlier data, it is absorbed poorly (Heaney RP Am J Clin Nutr 1990. PMID 2321572).

Calcium works together with vitamin D (Ross AC J Am Diet Assoc 2011. PMID 21443983); how much vitamin D you need in winter is covered in the article Vitamin D in winter: how much you need and how to take it.

Tablets and fractures

Where the benefit shows. In the Cochrane review, vitamin D together with calcium slightly lowered the risk of hip fracture (9 studies, 49,853 people; relative risk 0.84) and of any fracture (0.95). At home, where there are about 8 hip fractures per 1000 older people per year, this means 1 fracture fewer; in care institutions, where there are about 54 per 1000, 9 fewer (Avenell A Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2014. PMID 24729336).

Home only. A review of 33 randomized trials (51,145 people over 50 living at home, not in care institutions): supplements of calcium, vitamin D or both were not linked to a lower risk of hip fracture or other fractures compared with placebo or no treatment (Zhao JG JAMA 2017. PMID 29279934). This review covers only people living at home; the Cochrane figures above for home and for care institutions were calculated from one shared relative risk.

Bone density. In the WHI study (Women's Health Initiative), 36,282 healthy postmenopausal women aged 50–79 took 1000 mg of calcium as calcium carbonate and 400 IU (10 µg) of vitamin D3, or placebo, for 7 years. Hip bone density on calcium with vitamin D was 1.06% higher (Jackson RD N Engl J Med 2006. PMID 16481635).

How to take it

How much you need a day

Count all the calcium for the day — from food and tablets together. The safe upper limit set by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) for adults, including pregnant and breastfeeding women, is 2500 mg a day: this much calcium from food and supplements was tolerated without adverse effects in long-term studies (EFSA NDA Panel EFSA J 2012. PMID 42016128). The US limit for adults is 2000–2500 mg a day (Chung M Ann Intern Med 2016. PMID 27776363). The handbook also calls 2.5 g a day safe for people with unimpaired calcium metabolism (Burgerstein, Handbuch Nährstoffe 2015, p. 96).

What hinders absorption

Only 25–35% of the calcium in dairy products and tablets is absorbed. Oxalic acid (oxalates, plentiful in spinach, rhubarb and cocoa), phytates, coffee and alcohol hinder absorption; excess salt and protein above 20% of dietary calories upset the calcium balance (Burgerstein, Handbuch Nährstoffe 2015, p. 94).

If you need tablets

Up to 500 mg elemental calcium at a time. If a larger dose is needed, it is split into several doses (Straub DA Nutr Clin Pract 2007. PMID 17507729).

Carbonate with food, citrate either way. Calcium carbonate is taken with meals; calcium citrate can also be taken on an empty stomach. It suits people with achlorhydria (when the stomach produces almost no acid) and those taking heartburn medicines — H2 blockers or proton pump inhibitors (PPIs) (Straub DA Nutr Clin Pract 2007. PMID 17507729).

Separately from iron. In 126 people, 300–600 mg of calcium lowered iron absorption by 50–60%, as did 165 mg of calcium from milk or cheese — in single tests with one meal; absorption of heme iron fell too (Hallberg L Am J Clin Nutr 1991. PMID 1984335).

Separately from levothyroxine. Calcium salts interfere with the absorption of levothyroxine (thyroid hormone in tablet form), so the two are taken 3–4 hours apart (Mana DL Medicina (B Aires) 2025. PMID 41109285).

Heart and kidneys

Heart. An updated 2016 review (4 randomised and 27 observational studies) showed that total calcium intake (food + supplements) up to 2000–2500 mg/day, with or without vitamin D, was not associated with the risk of heart disease in generally healthy adults (Chung M Ann Intern Med 2016. PMID 27776363). In an earlier 2010 meta-analysis, calcium without vitamin D (from 500 mg a day) was linked to heart attacks: in data from 8151 participants, 143 heart attacks in the calcium group versus 111 on placebo, 1.31 times more often (Bolland MJ BMJ 2010. PMID 20671013).

So it makes sense to get calcium primarily from food, and to take tablets only in the dose that is missing to reach the norm.

Kidneys. In WHI, the risk of kidney stones on calcium with vitamin D was 1.17 times higher than on placebo (Jackson RD N Engl J Med 2006. PMID 16481635), and in the Cochrane review kidney disease was slightly more common (relative risk 1.16) (Avenell A Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2014. PMID 24729336). The handbook notes that this link was not confirmed in observational studies in the US (Burgerstein, Handbuch Nährstoffe 2015, p. 96), and EFSA does not consider it established (EFSA NDA Panel EFSA J 2012. PMID 42016128).

Who should see a doctor first

  • In hyperparathyroidism (overactive parathyroid glands) and in vitamin D poisoning, calcium supplements are contraindicated (Burgerstein, Handbuch Nährstoffe 2015, p. 96).
  • If you have had kidney stones or have kidney disease, discuss your calcium dose with a doctor (Jackson RD N Engl J Med 2006. PMID 16481635; Avenell A Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2014. PMID 24729336).
  • If you take vitamin D, especially calcitriol, your doctor may check your blood calcium: a mild rise to 2.6–2.8 mmol/L (10.4–11.2 mg/dL) occurred more often than on placebo (Avenell A Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2014. PMID 24729336).
  • If you have heart disease, start calcium tablets only after discussing it with a doctor.

What else supports bones

Bottom line

Bones need calcium throughout life, and food is the place to start. Tablets with vitamin D slightly lower the risk of hip fracture: with the same relative risk, at home that is about 1 fewer fracture per 1000 people per year, and in care institutions, where fractures are more common, about 9. Tablets make up only the dose that is missing to reach the norm. You can work out whether your diet provides enough calcium and decide whether you need tablets at a consultation.

Source: Calcium tablets: are they needed for bones, and do they harm the heart — universum.earth. Dr. Pereligyn.

Come back
Request a call back