Key points
The autoimmune protocol (AIP) is a phased diet: foods are removed for a time and then brought back. The table shows what studies of the protocol in Hashimoto's thyroiditis found and what is known about supplements in thyroiditis.
| Where | How it helps | What human studies showed |
|---|---|---|
| Well-being in Hashimoto's thyroiditis | a ten-week supported programme: food elimination, coaching, physician support, lifestyle | quality of life on the SF-36 improved significantly across all eight subscales: vitality, median 23 → 58, general health 40 → 70 (p < 0.0001); 16 women who completed the programme (Abbott RD, Cureus 2019) |
| Symptom burden | the same programme | the symptom questionnaire score fell from 92 to 29 points (p < 0.0001) |
| Inflammation marker hs-CRP | fell during the same programme | fell by 29%, from 1.63 to 1.15 mg/L (p = 0.022) |
| TPO antibodies in thyroiditis | selenium | meta-analysis of 35 randomised trials: selenium lowered TPO antibodies and, in patients not on replacement therapy, slightly lowered TSH (Huwiler VV, Thyroid 2024) |
| TPO and thyroglobulin antibodies in thyroiditis | vitamin D | meta-analysis of 12 randomised trials in 862 patients: a reduction in TPO and thyroglobulin antibodies (Tang J, Medicine 2023) |
How it helps
The autoimmune protocol is the most radical of the popular diets in Hashimoto's. Where a gluten-free diet removes one protein, this one removes all grains, legumes, dairy, eggs, nuts and seeds, nightshades, alcohol, coffee, sweeteners and a range of additives. What stays on the plate is meat, fish, vegetables other than nightshades, fruit and fats, and the protocol itself is built in phases: elimination is meant to be followed by bringing foods back. In the two existing studies the elimination phase ran 10 and 12 weeks — every figure discussed below comes from those durations.
The idea the protocol rests on is increased intestinal permeability: remove the irritating foods, the reasoning goes, and antigen traffic falls, taking the autoimmune response down with it. That mechanism is covered separately, in the piece on intestinal permeability. This article is about something else: whether the diet built on it works.
The protocol has been tested in two interventional studies specifically in Hashimoto's thyroiditis:
- Abbott and colleagues, 2019: 17 women aged 20–45 recruited, 16 completed, 10 weeks (Abbott RD, Cureus 2019).
- Ihnatowicz and colleagues, 2023: 28 people including one man, 12 weeks (Ihnatowicz P, Ann Agric Environ Med 2023).
Well-being
In the first study people felt markedly better — both in quality of life and in symptom count, and the effect size there is large (figures in the «Key points» table). The improvement in well-being is real, and it was measured.
Of the pre-specified measures, the systemic inflammation marker hs-CRP changed significantly — it fell during the intervention (see «Key points»).
The improvement came within a supported programme. In the first study participants received not a list of prohibitions but a ten-week programme:
- a team of a physician, nutritional therapy practitioners and certified health coaches;
- education and support by email and in a private group;
- a separate lifestyle component: sleep, stress management, movement, time outdoors, support systems;
- in week five, individual dietary recommendations built from each participant's own test results.
Supplements in thyroiditis
Selenium. The most robust data. In a meta-analysis of 35 randomised trials selenium lowered TPO antibodies and, in patients not on replacement therapy, slightly lowered TSH; adverse event rates did not differ from control (Huwiler VV, Thyroid 2024). In a network meta-analysis comparing supplements against each other, selenium was the only intervention left standing (Peng B, Front Endocrinol 2024).
Vitamin D. A meta-analysis of 12 randomised trials in 862 patients with thyroiditis showed a reduction in TPO and thyroglobulin antibodies (Tang J, Medicine 2023).
How to follow the protocol
The autoimmune protocol is built from three phases: elimination, reintroduction, maintenance. Bringing foods back is not an option or a sign of weakness — it is a constitutive part of the design.
Do not get stuck in the first phase: the review authors put it bluntly — the protocol is not a dietary pattern that can be implemented for life, and remaining in the elimination phase puts a person at risk of nutrient deficiencies and malnutrition (Pardali EC, Metabol Open 2025).
Elimination does not impoverish a diet automatically; it impoverishes it when what was removed is not replaced. In a large French cohort of 20,456 people without celiac disease, those who restricted gluten ate more fruit and vegetables and less sugar, salt and alcohol on average — their diet was closer to a healthy pattern, not worse (Perrin L, Br J Nutr 2019).
What to test before starting
- Tissue transglutaminase antibodies and total IgA — before removing gluten. On a gluten-free diet celiac disease stops being diagnosable, and the person risks going without an answer for a long time. In autoimmune thyroid disease celiac disease is biopsy-confirmed in about 1.6% — pooled across 6,024 patients — and more often in children with thyroiditis, at 6.2% (Roy A, Thyroid 2016).
- TSH, free T4, TPO antibodies — the baseline without which later changes have nothing to be compared to.
- Vitamin D, ferritin, vitamin B12 — the things elimination can worsen and that are worth knowing in advance.
- Weight — to separate the effect of dietary composition from the effect of a caloric deficit.
Who should see a doctor first
In intestinal strictures (narrowing of the bowel) the protocol is unsuitable. In inflammatory bowel disease without strictures — only under medical supervision. Nor is it suitable with a history of disordered eating, in pregnancy, in adolescence or in underweight.
| Situation | Reasonable? |
|---|---|
| Goal is well-being, duration limited to the elimination phase, someone to check in with | Cautiously yes |
| Confirmed celiac disease | A gluten-free diet is mandatory, but that is not AIP |
| Goal is lowering antibodies or stopping levothyroxine | No — there are no data for it |
| Intestinal strictures | No |
| Inflammatory bowel disease without strictures | Only under medical supervision |
| History of disordered eating | No |
| Pregnancy, adolescence, underweight | No |
| Celiac disease not yet ruled out by testing | Test first, decide after |
Direct harm. In people with intestinal strictures the protocol can be dangerous: reported events include symptom aggravation severe enough to prevent finishing the programme, and hospitalisation with partial small bowel obstruction after excessive raw vegetable intake (Pardali EC, Metabol Open 2025).
Nutrients. Adults who had avoided wheat for years without a diagnosis frequently fell short on fibre and calcium, and many had dropped dairy as well (Golley S, Nutr Diet 2019).
Microbiota. In ten healthy volunteers, a month of gluten-free eating was accompanied by a fall in bifidobacteria and lactobacilli and a rise in enterobacteria (De Palma G, Br J Nutr 2009). In a later study, sixteen weeks of low-gluten eating in healthy adults was accompanied by reduced microbiota richness and a lower share of bacteria considered beneficial (Delmas E, Nutrients 2025).
Selenium. Selenium carries a harm signal beyond the thyroid: in a randomised trial, taking 200 µg daily over an average of 7.7 years was accompanied by a higher incidence of type 2 diabetes (Stranges S, Ann Intern Med 2007).
Iodine. Excess is associated with more frequent autoimmune thyroiditis: over five years of follow-up the incidence was 0.2% with mild iodine deficiency, 1.0% with more than adequate intake and 1.3% with excessive intake (Teng W, N Engl J Med 2006).
Bottom line
In a study of 16 women with Hashimoto's thyroiditis, within a supported programme built around the autoimmune protocol, quality of life improved across all eight subscales and symptom burden fell from 92 to 29 points. If the goal is to feel better, and the person is ready for a time-limited, supported programme that ends with foods coming back, that decision has a real, if still modest, basis.
Before starting — tests, above all for celiac disease, before gluten is removed. Among supplements in thyroiditis, the most robust data belong to selenium.
Source: The Autoimmune Protocol (AIP) in Hashimoto's Thyroiditis: What Two Studies Actually Showed — universum.earth. Dr. Pereligyn.
