Key points
Five ways to sleep better without medication, each with meta-analysis data in people. Below — what exactly the studies showed and how to apply it.
| Remedy | What it helps with | What studies in people showed |
|---|---|---|
| Cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia (CBT-I) | Teaches you to fall asleep and stay asleep | 20 trials, 1,162 people: sleep onset 19 min faster, awakenings 26 min shorter, sleep efficiency +9.9 percentage points (Trauer 2015) |
| Music before bed | Calmer sleep onset, better sleep quality | Cochrane 2022, 13 trials, 1,007 people: sleep quality on the PSQI better by 2.79 points out of 21 (Jespersen 2022) |
| Warm bath or shower | Faster sleep onset | 17 studies: water 40–42.5 °C 1–2 h before bed, from 10 min — associated with significantly faster sleep onset and better sleep quality and efficiency (Haghayegh 2019) |
| Regular physical activity | Better sleep quality, faster sleep onset | 66 studies: moderate effect on sleep quality, small-to-medium on sleep onset (Kredlow 2015) |
| Mindfulness meditation | Better sleep quality | 18 trials, 1,654 people: better than placebo-type activities, effect holds at follow-up (Rusch 2019) |
Cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia
CBT-I is not “talking about problems” but a set of concrete techniques: bed only for sleep, getting up at the same time, cutting time in bed down to actual sleep, working with anxious thoughts (“I won’t fall asleep again”) and relaxation. In the trials, programmes included at least three such techniques (Trauer JM Ann Intern Med 2015. PMID 26054060).
A meta-analysis of 20 randomised trials, 1,162 people with chronic insomnia (64% women, mean age 56): sleep onset 19.0 minutes faster, wake after sleep onset 26.0 minutes shorter, sleep efficiency — the share of time in bed actually spent asleep — 9.9 percentage points higher. The improvements seemed to hold at later measurements, and no adverse outcomes were reported (Trauer JM Ann Intern Med 2015. PMID 26054060).
On average, sleep onset was 19 minutes faster and night-time wakefulness 26 minutes shorter than in the control groups. That is why CBT-I is recommended as first-line treatment for chronic insomnia — before pills. More on sleep hygiene in the article “Insomnia: the sleep formula”.
Music before bed
A 2022 Cochrane review: 13 trials, 1,007 adults with sleep complaints. Participants listened to recorded music for 25–60 minutes every day — from three days to three months (Jespersen KV Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2022. PMID 36000763).
Sleep quality on the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI; scale 0–21, lower is better) improved by 2.79 points compared with those who changed nothing — 10 trials, 708 people, moderate-certainty evidence; in size that is about one standard deviation. By participants’ own accounts sleep may have come sooner, lasted longer and been more efficient (3 trials, 197 people, low certainty). No trial reported any adverse events (Jespersen KV Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2022. PMID 36000763).
How to apply: calm music without lyrics or familiar slow pieces, played quietly, 25–60 minutes before bed, every evening. The effect builds up over a course, not in one evening.
Warm bath or shower
The 2019 meta-analysis gathered 17 studies, 13 of them entered the calculations. Water at 40–42.5 °C was associated with better sleep quality and efficiency as rated by participants themselves, and a bath or shower 1–2 hours before bed lasting as little as 10 minutes — with significantly faster sleep onset (Haghayegh S Sleep Med Rev 2019. PMID 31102877).
The proposed mechanism: warm water widens the vessels of the palms and soles, the body sheds heat through the skin more actively, and core temperature falls faster — and it is this fall that the body reads as the signal for sleep; the exact mechanism is still being studied (Haghayegh S Sleep Med Rev 2019. PMID 31102877).
How to apply: not scalding, but pleasantly warm water at 40–42.5 °C; 1–2 hours before bed, not right before it; 10–15 minutes. The meta-analysis included both baths and showers.
Regular physical activity
A meta-analysis of 66 studies: regular exercise gave a moderate improvement in sleep quality, a small-to-medium speeding up of sleep onset, and a small increase in total sleep time and sleep efficiency. Even a single workout slightly improved sleep, and night-time waking after it was shorter (Kredlow MA J Behav Med 2015. PMID 25596964).
An important detail: no effect of exercise intensity or of its aerobic or strength character was found; the result depended on sex, age, baseline activity, type of exercise, time of day, duration and how well the person stuck to the programme (Kredlow MA J Behav Med 2015. PMID 25596964).
In people aged 60 and over with insomnia, the Cochrane review found one trial of 43 people: after an exercise programme sleep onset became faster, sleep longer and the overall sleep rating better; sleep efficiency did not change significantly (Montgomery P Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2002. PMID 12519595).
How to apply: any activity you enjoy and can keep up regularly — walking, cycling, swimming, strength training. No effect of intensity was found in the meta-analysis — sticking to the programme matters more.
Mindfulness meditation
A meta-analysis of 18 randomised trials, 1,654 people: compared with placebo-type activities matched for time and attention, mindfulness meditation improved sleep quality — effect size 0.33 right after the course and 0.54 at follow-up, moderate-strength evidence (Rusch HL Ann N Y Acad Sci 2019. PMID 30575050).
How to apply: 10–20 minutes a day — observing the breath, the body, sounds without judgement; a course of several weeks. Suits those kept awake by racing thoughts. On the link between stress and sleep — see “The stress axis, sleep and energy”.
How to combine them: a four-week plan
- Week 1. Get up at the same time every day, weekends included; 30 minutes of movement during the day; 1–2 hours before bed — a warm bath or shower for 10–15 minutes.
- Week 2. Add music for 25–60 minutes before bed; bed is for sleep only; if you cannot sleep for longer than 20 minutes — get up and come back when you feel sleepy.
- Week 3. Add 10–20 minutes of mindfulness meditation during the day or evening; cut time in bed down to actual sleep plus half an hour.
- Week 4. Review the sleep diary: how long you take to fall asleep, how many times you wake. If there is no improvement — time to talk to a doctor.
Who should see a doctor first
- Insomnia for longer than three months, three nights a week or more.
- Snoring with pauses in breathing, daytime sleepiness at the wheel — sleep apnoea needs to be ruled out.
- Low mood, anxiety, pain or another illness that disturbs sleep.
- Choosing treatment, including medication, is done individually with a doctor: the remedies in this article complement it, they do not replace it.
Source: 5 drug-free remedies for insomnia: Cochrane and meta-analyses — universum.earth. Dr. Pereligyn.
